Challenging misleading healthcare claims

How to complain

There are several steps you can take to challenge misleading claims:

  • Find claims you think are misleading
  • Confirm they are misleading
  • Find out if the claims are covered by any standards or regulator
  • Find out who is making the claims and check if he/she is a member of a statutory or voluntary regulator
  • Gather information and decide how to challenge the claims
  • Write your complaint
  • Submit your complaint
  • Tell us the results!

Find claims you think are misleading

This is easy. They are all around us!

arroworangeSee Where to find misleading claims for further details.

Confirm they are misleading

This could be easy or difficult. Many claims are obviously misleading because they are scientifically implausible (eg claims about homeopathy, crystal healing, ear candles). Others might take a bit of research to see whether the claims have already been tested. But remember that in most cases you do not have to show claims are misleading: all you have to do is question claims that might be misleading. It is up to the regulator to make a decisions whether they breach the rules, regulations and laws.

However, although you may find good evidence that specific claims are inaccurate, the regulator or the organisation overseeing the advert will have rules about what is and what isn't considered to be misleading and will only be concerned about whether these rules are being breached.

Books

As so many of the misleading claims that appear in advertising to the public are made by practitioners of complementary and alternative therapies, you may want to find out more about these. The following books are recommended (with links to amazon.co.uk):

arrowgreenTrick or Treatment? Alternative Medicine on Trial by Simon Singh & Edzard Ernst

arrowgreenBad Science by Ben Goldacre

arrowgreenSuckers: How Alternative Medicine Makes Fools of Us All by Rose Shapiro

Websites

There are many websites that deal with alternative therapies and misleading claims:

arrowgreenSee Robert Carroll's The Skeptic's Dictionary for excellent information on all sorts of alternative therapies

arrowgreenSee ebm-first — a comprehensive resource of what alternative health practitioners might not tell you

Previous complaints

It is also worthwhile checking previous decisions by regulators to see if there have been any similar cases in the past. But don't limit your searches to just the regulator you think is relevant to your complaint; you may be able to learn from what other regulators have said and be able to improve the effectiveness of your complaint.

Also check our News and Results pages to see what complaints we have already made.

Find out who is making the claims

It will usually be obvious who is making the claim, whether it is an individual or a private or public company. If a product or service is being sold, then you should have an address or contact details. However, some investigation may be required. Most newspapers and magazines require advertisers to give their details in the advert, but you may come across some adverts on the Internet where it's not clear who is responsible for the website.

arroworangeRead How to find out who owns a website

arroworangeComing soon: How to find out who the directors  of a company are.

Check if he/she is a member of a statutory or voluntary regulator

Who you submit a complaint to depends on what the claim is, where it is being made and who is making it.

arroworangeRead Who to complain to for details of the different organisations you can complain to.

Remember that if the misleading claims you have found fall within the remit of more than one regulator, you can complain to them all.

Write your complaint

arroworangeRead Writing a complaint for advice and helpful hints.

Complaints should be made in your own name: even though you may have used advice from our website, please do not suggest that you are submitting a complaint on our behalf or imply that you are associated with the Nightingale Collaboration.

Submit your complaint

This can be done either on the Internet or by letter, depending on what the organisation provides.

Remember to keep copies of everything you send them.

Tell us the results!

Tell us so we can highlight your results to others. Even if your complaint was not successful, tell us so others can benefit and make future challenges more successful.

Newsletter

To subscribe to our Newsletter, enter your details below and click Subscribe.
You will receive a confirmation email. Please click on the link in the email to confirm your subscription.